Investment Thesis
When it involves portfolio technique, as traders we are sometimes our personal worst enemies. Equity traders have a behavior of timing the market poorly, and it normally ends in extreme underperformance relative to the broad market indexes.
An eye-opening study from Dalbar confirmed that fairness traders had underperformed the S&P 500 over each examined time horizon. During the examined 30-year interval the S&P returned 11.06% yearly, whereas traders in fairness funds solely yielded a mean of 3.79%. $10,000 invested within the S&P 500 would have been value $232,664 after 30 years, however the common investor was solely in a position to flip their $10,000 into $30,526 in the identical time-frame.
If shopping for and holding the index outperforms the common fairness investor, why not simply buy-and-hold a low-cost index fund just like the Vanguard Total Stock Market Fund (VT)? That is a possible resolution, however most traders do not need the abdomen for the volatility that fairness funds expertise. After a big drawdown, traders are simply spooked and have been recognized to promote their property at inopportune occasions. It is all too widespread to listen to of traders who bought on the backside in 2008 or 2009 and by no means reinvested, lacking out on the large bull run of the final decade.
Trend-following gives an answer to this drawback. The premise of a trend-following portfolio is easy: when the market is in an uptrend the portfolio ought to have publicity to equities, and when the market is in a downtrend the portfolio ought to keep away from market publicity by investing in money or equivalents. Studies akin to Meb Faber’s white paper “A Quantitative Approach to Tactical Asset Allocation” have proven that trend-following has traditionally offered equity-like returns with bond-like volatility and drawdowns. Trend-followers are typically in a position to sidestep giant drawdowns by eliminating market publicity throughout bear markets.
But trend-following is extensively {followed} and practiced. Meb’s white paper is the #1 most downloaded doc within the SSRN database. Looking ahead, some traders specific doubt that trend-following will proceed to offer risk-adjusted market outperformance to those that observe it. Others warn that promoting can probably lead to a “whipsaw” state of affairs through which a triggered promote is {followed} virtually instantly by a purchase at the next value. These issues are certainly legitimate.
Is it doable to make use of this widely-followed indicator to guard your portfolio from drawdowns with out sacrificing whole return? Recent value motion within the world stock market suggests it’s.
Creating a Diversified Trend-Following Portfolio With Just One Stock
The fantastic thing about trend-following is that one can observe the technique in quite a lot of methods. Similar to how worth traders concentrate on totally different basic metrics like value to earnings, value to guide, or enterprise multiples, trend-followers can use a big selection of technical indicators to assemble a rules-based trend-following portfolio.
One of essentially the most {followed} technical indicators of the pattern is the exponential 200-day transferring common (200 DMA) for a given safety. This metric takes a weighted common value of a safety over the past 200 days, giving extra weight to latest days and fewer weight to days additional previously. If the safety is buying and selling above its 200 DMA, it’s thought of to be in an uptrend. If the safety is buying and selling under its 200 DMA, it’s thought of to be in a downtrend.
The Vanguard Total World Stock ETF is an efficient manner for traders to achieve publicity to the stock market. With an expense ratio at simply ten foundation factors and publicity to the complete world’s stock market, it’s a low cost and diversified fund. The incontrovertible fact that it’s an exchange-traded fund moderately than a mutual fund additionally means it’s extra tax environment friendly, as mutual funds are required to distribute capital features to shareholders yearly. It is an acceptable fund for fairness publicity.
To exhibit the efficacy of trend-following, we’ll analyze the efficiency of a easy trend-following technique in comparison with buy-and-hold investing in a portfolio of VT stock. The portfolio technique might be as follows:
1. If VT is buying and selling above its 200 DMA, keep 100% publicity to VT.
2. If VT is buying and selling under its 200 DMA, keep 100% publicity to money.
Rules-based portfolios typically do not get a lot easier than that. The mannequin portfolio had little exercise throughout 2018, as VT bounced alongside its 200 DMA for many of the yr:
VT knowledge by YCharts
Comparing 2018 Portfolio Performance to Buy and Hold
Now that 2018 is coming to a detailed, an ideal alternative to check the efficiency of this straightforward trend-following portfolio has offered itself. We will be capable of see if the technique mitigated drawdowns in portfolio worth in 2018.
For simplicity, we’ll assume the next:
-
Buys and sells can solely happen at market open,
-
there are not any fee prices,
-
the portfolio reinvests dividends when paid,
-
the portfolio can all the time keep absolutely invested by way of fractional shares, and
-
the money portion of the portfolio paid no curiosity.
VT crossed under its 200 DMA on April 2nd. At market open on April third, the portfolio bought its VT for $72.66. VT crossed above its 200 DMA simply a few days later, so the portfolio purchased again into VT on April fifth for $73.90.
The subsequent promote was triggered in June when VT crossed under its 200 DMA on June 22nd. On June 25th (the subsequent buying and selling day), the portfolio bought its VT place for $73.89 at market open. The portfolio repurchased VT shares for $73.54 on July fifth at market open because the VT crossed above its 200 DMA on July third.
The remaining promote of 2018 was triggered when the portfolio crossed under its 200 DMA on October fifth. On October eighth (the subsequent buying and selling day) the portfolio bought its VT place for $74.03 per share at market open. The portfolio by no means purchased again into its VT place, and in the present day would sitting in 100% money.
The following desk illustrates the portfolio actions and general efficiency:
Chart: Author, Data from YCharts and Yahoo! Finance
Year up to now, the pattern pattern following portfolio has returned -0.56% which is nothing to write down dwelling about. At one level, the portfolio was even shedding to buy-and-hold when the promote sign in April turned out to be a false alarm, and the portfolio was pressured to purchase again into VT at the next value.
But when in comparison with buy-and-hold, the pattern following portfolio crushed it:
VT Total Return Price knowledge by YCharts
Because the trend-following portfolio “sat out” the newest drawdown, it by no means noticed the 14+% decline that the buy-and-hold portfolio noticed. As a consequence, the straightforward trend-following portfolio outperformed the buy-and-hold portfolio by a whopping 11.8% year-to-date, thanks largely to sitting in money for the latest market turbulence. The portfolio achieved this 11.8% outperformance by making use of simply two fundamental, quantitative guidelines.
Investor Takeaways & Conclusion
Trend-following has labored previously to guard traders from critical drawdowns in portfolio worth, and it demonstrated its value throughout this yr’s brutal selloff. By implementing a rules-based trend-following plan, traders can defend their hard-earned capital by avoiding downward-trending markets.
For this pattern portfolio, I used the simplest state of affairs I may consider: a portfolio that consists of only a whole stock market fund that’s absolutely invested when the ETF is above the 200 DMA and sitting in money when the ETF is under the 200 DMA. But because of the flexibility of portfolio methods, traders can design a trend-following portfolio nonetheless they see match to fulfill their objectives. Investors can use indicators like easy transferring averages, relative strength indices, and technical evaluation in establishing a trend-following portfolio. Different methods will be tailor-made to suit totally different portfolios.
For occasion, an investor sitting on a large pile of appreciated stock in a taxable account might assume they do not have the posh of using a pattern following technique as a result of promoting out of the portfolio will create a tax occasion. But an clever investor can make use of a rule akin to shorting materially comparable safety when their place is trending all the way down to get rid of publicity to the place in a downward-trending market. This hedging will be achieved by way of brief gross sales or put choices. Though any features on the brief place might be taxable, the investor is not going to be pressured to promote their appreciated securities, preserving the tax deferral advantages of a buy-and-hold technique.
While many traders declare buy-and-hold is the one approach to make investments, trend-following presents a singular alternative to take part in fairness upside whereas mitigating draw back. Even utilizing widely-followed technical indicators, trend-followers can navigate uneven markets with relative ease. For these traders who’re unable to resist the portfolio drawdown of a buy-and-hold technique, trend-following methods are value a re-examination.
Disclosure: I/we now have no positions in any shares talked about, and no plans to provoke any positions throughout the subsequent 72 hours. I wrote this text myself, and it expresses my very own opinions. I’m not receiving compensation for it (aside from from Seeking Alpha). I’ve no enterprise relationship with any firm whose stock is talked about on this article.
Additional disclosure: This article is for informational functions solely and shouldn’t be relied upon for funding selections. No reference to any particular safety constitutes a suggestion to purchase, promote or maintain that safety or every other safety. Nothing from this writer shall be thought of a solicitation or supply to purchase or promote any safety, future, choice or different monetary instrument or to supply or present any funding recommendation or service to any person in any jurisdiction. Nothing contained within the article constitutes funding recommendation or gives any opinion in regards to the suitability of any safety, and the views expressed by this writer shouldn’t be taken as recommendation to purchase, promote or maintain any safety.
